neither...
CoreCase's are a 1000 times better and not as expensive. Both Switcheasy and InCase cases are plastic they look great for about 1 week and then they get scratched and banged up. I've had 5 different CoreCase cases over the last 3 years including the iPhone iPod nano x2 video and classic and every one of the cases and the iPods/iphones still look brand new. I find buying what 'everyone' else is buying makes you look like a sheep or worst still liking buying Microsoft products ;o)